The Old Mill Cafe & Restaurant
Food & Beverage · Cafe & Restaurant

The Old Mill Cafe & Restaurant

12 Pym St, Millthorpe, New South Wales, 2798

Google Maps Updated: 25 May 2026
Authenticity Score: 85/100
About

This cafe is a local favorite known for its famous lemon meringue pie and hearty pies. Most diners love the cozy, heritage vibe and friendly service. A few visitors have had issues with slow service or inconsistent food quality during busy times, but the majority find it a great bang for the buck. It is a must-visit spot in Millthorpe.

Our Review Process
20
Most Relevant
15
Newest
20
Highest rating
18
Lowest rating

We analyze 73 public reviews for The Old Mill Cafe & Restaurant using our data models and filter out spam to highlight only authentic feedback.

Performance Scores
Food Taste 79/100
Value for Money 75/100
Pro Tip

Get there early for the lemon meringue pie, as they sell out fast!

Indoor/Outdoor seating
Local wines available
Pros & Cons

✓ What Works Well

  • Famous lemon meringue pie
  • Cozy atmosphere
  • Friendly owners

✗ Areas to Improve

  • Slow service during peak hours
  • Inconsistent food quality
  • Noisy when full
Frequently Asked Questions
  • Do you take bookings?
  • Are there gluten-free options?
  • Is it dog friendly?
User Feedback

The pies are a highlight

Great spot for a weekend brunch

Service can be unorganized when busy

Quick Info